I am passionate about website usability. Good copy is an important part of that but not everything. So I asked John Allwright, head of web design and development at Microsoft UK, and John Harris, a user experience evangelist there, to talk about what makes websites good.
Full disclosure: my company, Articulate Marketing, does a lot of work for Microsoft, although this conversation was triggered by an article on the BBC’s website, websites face four-second cut-off. This reported that 75% of users would not return to websites that took longer than four seconds to load.
What are the most common usability problems you deal with at Microsoft?
John Allwright: The same problems that any large corporation faces. It comes down to how you do content management. Everyone wants to be on the front page of Microsoft.com and obviously, they can’t be. The number of pages you can host is endless (actually in the order 5m pages across the whole of Microsoft) but then it becomes an issue of navigation.
How important is search to usability and navigation?
John Allwright: We do surveys of how people find information about our products. Generally, they come to it through a search engine (obviously Live.com!). We’d like people to access the information more easily from within the site.
It’s interesting how people perceive websites. When asked where they got some information, people will quote the search engine [that they used to find a piece of information] rather than the site that served it up.
John Harris. It’s increasingly a case that people arrive at a landing page and do a search rather than spend three or four minutes browsing. Whichever search engine you used, trying to find the right document among 150,000 pages is quite difficult. People expect to see a search box. It’s not just best practice but it’s now an expectation.
Is loading speed still relevant with so many people on broadband?
John Allwright: It’s still a problem. There are a whole bunch of things that can contribute to slow loading. Even with broadband, some sites still seem to take an age to load. Loading times are a user experience issue. If you can’t deliver your pages quick enough, there are lots of other people out there who can do it better.
John Harris: A lot of people get fixated on home page download speed. What they fail to appreciate is that if the server is on a heavy load, the speed might very. Big ecommerce sites actually see sales drop off in real time on slow servers. Sometimes, a slow response isn’t down to the site design. It can be an internet blockage or a slow server. Equally, you can have a page load instantly and then pop up an advert that takes a while. Bingo, you’ve lost them.
Why do sites get so bloated?
John Harris: it’s a lot of different factors. Quite often, it’s the difficulty of standing up to a client that is demanding, say, flash intro animations. The large agencies and big design companies deliver really good, compelling websites. In the mid market, the designers perhaps feel uncomfortable standing up to clients.
Another reason is that a lot of companies struggle with the whole idea of user experience. They like the sound of it but then it is ‘show me the cold hard facts.’ There’s always a moment of scepticism around user experience because you can’t prove the point until you’ve made the changes.
It’s also a question, often, of making small, detail changes. Too often there seems to be a sense that people need to replace a whole website with another website when optimising the way a single form works could be more effective. User experience isn’t about building a whole website but about concentrating on where it goes wrong.
Web 2.0 – myth, reality or promise?
John Allwright: My personal opinion is that it’s a useful vehicle for discussing the state of the web. Some people see it as gradient shades, rounded corner and a bit of AJAX. But there are more fundamental things at work. For example, demographic changes, increasing broadband and user-contributed data mean that new business models spring out of it. It’s a way of reflecting on what is possible now. I don’t want ring fence it with any particular technology or any particular vendor. People’s definitions vary but that doesn’t matter.
What does it mean for Microsoft?
John Allwright: We’ve debated this long and hard in the UK. What it means to us is to be a voice at the table when people are talking about it. To have something to add to the discussion. Of course, some of it is tactical – we have an AJAX offering, for example. But strategically, it’s about engaging in the right discussions and not being excluded.
John Harris: From a design perspective, what I really like and what Microsoft is getting is the ability to push better, more interesting interaction. It is a great time for people to be building stuff, playing around with ideas. From my side of the table, I don’t think there’s any scepticism around ‘Web 2.0’ but we do have to make the bets in the right place. It’s not like when the web took off in the first place when people charged in and tried to do as much as possible. It’s about making it all work together. It’s no good having great technologies for the sake of great technologies. We’re not being cautious. We’re making sure that what we release, when we release it, is usable.
What do bloggers need to learn about user experience and usability?
John Harris: I guess it’s how you treat your audience. A lot of people worry about frequency – should I blog every day? You get a lot of blogs where there are lots of one line link-based posts that don’t provide any additional information for readers. People are looking for consistency. Putting up a really interesting piece once a month could be good. It’s about finding your own style and rhythm.
There seems to be a lot of consistency between blog user interfaces from different vendors. Does that hamper usability or not?
John Allwright: RSS readers are very handy for getting nuggets of information. There might definitely be space for someone to take that to the next level where you have a richer experience more like reading a magazine online.
We’ve been working on a reader for the New York Times for some of their online content. [It has lots of different ways of navigating form article to article.] If your content becomes interesting and you can start relating blog posts to others within the same blog then it becomes more than a stream of consciousness.
How about a quick plug for your new design tools?
Microsoft Expression is a new family of programs aimed at designers that are focused on experience design. When most sites want something more than AJAX they look to Flash. A lot of times, it’s the right answer, but sometimes you want to go further or reach deeper into the capabilities of the desktop, such as 3D acceleration and Expression enables that.
Technorati Tags: usability, website, Microsoft Expression, John Harris, John Allwright, Microsoft, content management, blogs